Michaelina Wautier (Mond c.1617 - 1689 Brussels), Portrait of Martino Martini, Jesuit missionary in China, 1654. Oil on canvas. Signed and dated upper left: Michaelina Wautier fecit 1654. Chinese inscription upper right: Wei Kuangguo (Chinese title of the sitter). 69.5 x 59 cm. Estimate CHF 7 000 / 10 000. Sold for CHF 480 500. World auction record for the artist. Photo Koller
ZURICH.- The week of old masters and antiques auctions at Koller yielded numerous excellent results for works by artists such as Caspar David Freidrich and Osias Beert, and the nearly half a million Swiss francs realized by a portrait by Michaelina Wautier set a new world record price at auction for the artist.
Old Master Paintings
A mid-17th century portrait by Michaelina Wautier was one of the highlights of the Old Masters auction at Koller (lot 3057). Paintings by this Flemish artist are rare: only approximately 25 are known to exist. The last time Koller offered a painting by Wautier was in 2003, and it realized a then-record price of CHF 54 000. That record was left far behind when the portrait in this sale, depicting Jesuit missionary and mapmaker Martino Martini in Asian dress, surpassed all expectations and sold for CHF 480 500.
A floral still life by another 17th-century Flemish artist and pioneer of the genre, Osias Beert, shared the leading position in this sale, also realizing CHF 480 500 (lot 3031).
Osias Beert (circa 1580 Antwerp 1624), A still life with flowers in a woven basket and a floral bouquet in a porcelain vase on a table top with insects. Oil on panel. 39.1 x 64.3 cm. Estimate CHF 400 000 / 500 000. Sold for CHF 480 500. Photo Koller
Certificates: - Ingvar Bergström, 9.12.1975 and 24.4.1989.
- Marie-Louise Hairs, 26.5.1977.
- Laurens J. Bol, 28.5.1977.
- Dr. Walther Bernt, July 1978.
Provenance: - Aspelin collection, Sweden.
- Count Carl von Rosen collection, Stockholm, circa 1913.
- Sale Bukowskis, Stockholm, 1920s.
- Gösta Stenman Gallery, Stockholm, 1934.
- Counsellor Wallin collection, Stockholm.
- Sale Bukowskis, Stockholm, 6.11.1975, lot 5.
- Richard Green Gallery, London, 1976-77.
- Private collection Alfred Studer, Lichtenstein, acquired from the above.
- Swiss private collection.
Literature: - Granberg, Olof: Inventaire général des trésors d'art peintures & sculptures, principalement de maîtres étrangers (non-Scandinaves) en Suède, Vol. III, Stockholm 1913, no. 97.
- Hairs, Marie-Louise: Les peintres Flamands de fleurs au XVIIe siècle, Brussels 1985, no. 115, pp. 342-343 (ill.).
- Segal, Sam: Flowers and Nature, The Hague 1990, p. 183 (mentioned in footnote 2).
This painting is archived under No. 14703 at the RKD, The Hague, as a work by the hand of Osias Beert.
Osias Beert, along with Jan Brueghel the Elder (1568-1625) and Ambrosius Bosschaert the Elder (1573-1621), was one of the most important still life painters of the early 17th century. As one of the early pioneers working in still life painting as an independent genre, Beert played an important role in its development. Alongside paintings of richly laid-out tables and still lifes of fruit, Beert favoured floral compositions, often with a blue & white porcelain vase, as in the example offered here. The present work is masterfully executed, with an impressive motif enlivened by a wide palette of colours and several insects. The condition of the work is impeccable.
Lately rediscovered in a private collection, this is a masterwork by the artist, believed to have been painted after 1610. Only a few of Beert’s works were signed and none are dated, although two of his still lifes on copper are marked on the reverse with the date 1609.
In 1602 Beert was accepted into the Guild of Saint Luke of Antwerp, prior to which he trained under Andries van Baseroo. Beert most likely painted the majority of his floral still lifes during the 1610s, such as a work in a private collection (RKD Archiv Nr. 14707) which is closely related through its composition and style to the painting offered here.
For the seventeenth-century viewer, this still life would not only have represented a beautiful depiction of flowers, but would have carried strong symbolic connotations: the brief lifespan of the cut flowers calls to mind the brevity of human life, and the caterpillar and butterfly symbolize the resurrection of Christ.
Although the floral motifs of Jan Breughel the Elder certainly had some influence on Osias Beert’s artistic development, Beert brilliantly succeeded in developing his own formal language, and by combining a diversity of motifs in a harmonious manner, creates an atmosphere of exquisite opulence and luxurious plenitude that never ceases to fascinate and delight the senses.
Dr. Klara Alen, to whom we are grateful for her scholarly research on this painting, will include this work in her forthcoming monograph on the still lifes of Osias Beert.
19th Century Paintings
A series of works by Bavarian artist Eduard Grützner of figures in wine or beer cellars fetched prices significantly above their pre-sale estimates, such as the depiction of a brewmaster fully enjoying a quiet moment with a cigar and a beer (lot 3209, sold for CHF 67 700).
Eduard Grützner (Grosskarlowitz 1846 - 1925 Munich), Zigarre rauchender Braumeister, 1882. (Brew master smoking a cigar). Oil on panel. Signed and dated lower right: Ed. Grützner 1862. 46 x 37.4 cm. Estimate CHF 15 000 / 20 000. Sold for CHF 67 700. Photo Koller
Provenance: South German private collection since 1983.
Literature: Balogh, Laszlo: Eduard von Grützner. 1846 - 1925. Ein Münchner Genremaler der Gründerzeit. Monographie und kritisches Verzeichnis seiner Ölgemälde, Ölstudien und Ölskizzen, Munich 1991, p. 172, Cat. No. 80 (ill.).
A late landscape by Jean-Baptiste Camille Corot which was formerly in the collection of the 19th-century Scottish railway engineer James Staats Forbes changed hands for CHF 84 500 (lot 3214), and a magnificent view of the Port of Marseille by Félix François Ziem (lot 3205) sold for CHF 59 300.
Jean-Baptiste Camille Corot (1796 Paris 1875), Sous bois. Un tronc d'arbre abattu en travers d'un ruisseau, 1874. Oil on canvas. Signed and dated lower left: COROT 1874. 55 x 45 cm. Estimate CHF 60 000 / 90 000. Sold for CHF 84 500. Photo Koller
Provenance: - Collection of James Staats Forbes, circa 1891.
- Christie's, London, 14.6.1918, Lots 53 (wrong measurements).
- Private collection: W. Robinson.
- Christie's, London, 17.6.1927, Lots 89.
- Barbizon House, London.
- Collection of Lord Craigmyle, London.
- Christie's, New York, 27.5.1983, Lots 37.
- Galerie Widmer, St. Gallen.
- Private collection, Switzerland, acquired in 1986.
Literature: Robaut, Alfred: L'oeuvre de Corot. Catalogue raisonné et illustré, Vol III, Paris 1965, Cat. No. 2168, p. 303 (with wrong measurements. With ill.).
Félix François Ziem (Beaune 1821 - 1911 Paris), Le port de Marseille. Oil on panel. Signed lower left: Ziem. 73 x 57.5 cm. Estimate CHF 40 000 / 60 000. Sold for CHF 59 300. Photo Koller
Provenance: - Sotheby's, New York, 24.10.1946, Lot 81.
- Sotheby's, New York, 29.2.1956, Lot 63.
- Weinmüller auction, Munich, 2-3.10.1963, Lot 1169.
- Swiss private collection for several generations.
Literature: - Miquel, Pierre: Félix Ziem 1821-1911, Maurs-la-Jolie 1978, p. 198, No. 1405 (ill. entitled "Scène de Port (Marseille)").
- Burdin-Hellebranth, Anne: Félix Ziem 1821 - 1911, 1998, vol II, p. 105, No. 1280 (ill.).
Drawings
Another “portrait”, this time of a bare-limbed oak tree by Romantic artist Caspar David Friedrich (lot 3457), more than doubled its estimate at CHF 65 300. Formerly in the collection of the Kunsthalle in Mannheim, this work illustrates the intense attention that Friedrich gave to natural subjects.
Caspar David Friedrich (Greifswald 1774-1840 Dresden), Study of a tree, 18 April 1803. Estimate CHF 25 000 / 35 000. Sold for CHF 65 300. Photo Koller
Pencil on wove paper with brown ground. Dated in pencil at left lower edge: den 18t April 1803. Numbered in pencil on the lower right: 6. Old inscription on the reverse: Caspar David Friedrich. Von der Kunsthalle Mannheim erworben am 24. April 1919. Heinrich Sachs. 20.5 x 13.2 cm (the upper and lower right corners cut and with old supplements).
Provenance: - Kunsthalle Mannheim (until April 1919)
- Heinrich Sachs (1894-1946), acquired 24 April 1919
- Kunstkabinett Ketterer, Stuttgart 1951
- Swiss private collection
A wonderful depiction of Greek prime minister Alexandros Mavrokordatos (lot 3468) by Suzanne Eynard-Chatelain realized CHF 30 500, triple the pre-sale estimate. Mavrokordatos, a friend of Lord Byron and champion of Greek independence, is dressed as a freedom fighter in this lively portrait.
Suzanne Eynard-Chatelain (1775 - 1844), Portrait of Prince Alexandre Maurocordato as Greek freedom fighter in Turkish costume. Watercolour and chalk on paper. 73.5 x 58.4 cm. Framed. Estimate CHF 10 000 / 15 000. Sold for CHF 30 500. Photo Koller
Literature: Patrick-André Guerretta. Pierre-Louis De la Rive ou la belle nature, vie et oevre peint, Genève, 2002, S. 267 (Abb.)
Porcelain & Silver
The top lot of the Max Fahrländer collection was the very rare “Flaming Tortoise” Kakiemon-style plate with an inscribed Augustus Rex mark (lot 1737, sold for CHF 36 500), indicating that it was not only in Augustus III’s personal collection, but was among the wares produced during the Hoym-Lemaire scandal of the 1730s.
A very rare “Flaming Tortoise” plate from the collection of Augustus III, King of Poland and Elector of Saxony (1733-1763), Meissen, ca. 1729-1731. Estimate CHF 10 000 / 15 000. Sold for CHF 30 500. Photo Koller
With incised AR monogram from 1734. Enamel blue swords and incised AR monogram, blackened. D 24,8 cm.
Provenance: - Collection Dr. Max Fahrländer, Basel-Riehen.
- Private collection via inheritance, Winterthur.
The von Hoym–Lemaire Scandal
This extremely rare plate is a witness to an eighteenth-century Franco-Saxon scandal complete with deception, greed, and the downfall of a powerful minister. Behind the scandal, however, lies one of the greatest early financial successes for the Meissen porcelain manufactory.
In the second half of the 17th century, collecting porcelain from the Far East was a passionate hobby for many wealthy European merchants and nobles. Kaolin (the special clay required to make porcelain) had not yet been discovered in Europe, and these fabulous and fragile wares had to be shipped halfway around the world. The pieces that arrived intact were consequently rare and exceedingly expensive.
All of this changed in the early years of the 18th century, when August the Strong’s royal porcelain manufactory at Meissen in Saxony discovered the secret of pure white porcelain. For the first time, a European manufactory could produce wares to rival those of China and Japan. Meissen had found the magic formula – but would wealthy collectors used to the original Asian wares purchase these European imitations?
Meissen’s products, mainly decorated with chinoiserie motifs, enjoyed a certain success throughout its first two decades of existence, but competition from other European manufactories – and especially from the Asian products themselves – was strong. The idea for Meissen’s breakthrough product was to come from an unlikely source: a French ceramics merchant, Rodolphe Lemaire.
The son and grandson Parisian ceramics and glass dealers (but left to start from scratch after his debt-ridden father’s death), Lemaire observed the rising popularity of Japanese “Kakiemon” wares with great interest. Collectors – including August the Strong himself – were paying huge sums to have such pieces shipped from Japan. In 1728 Lemaire wrote to August the Strong, proposing a deal: Lemaire would supply models of Asian porcelain from his own collection to the Meissen workshop. In return, the Meissen craftsmen would produce reproductions of these models and sell them to Lemaire for exclusive distribution on the French market.
In order to achieve this plan, Lemaire enlisted the aid of Count Karl Heinrich von Hoym. Ambassador to the court of Versailles for Saxony and Poland throughout the 1720s, von Hoym was also a passionate collector of porcelain, and probably a client of Lemaire. When the Count was recalled to Saxony in 1729 to become minister of Internal Affairs and director of the Meissen manufactory, he was in the perfect situation to assist Lemaire in his mercantile schemes.
Together they managed to convince Augustus to supply Lemaire with the Meissen porcelain he needed. Some wares Lemaire ordered undecorated, which he sent to Holland to be painted in the fashionable Kakiemon style (the Dutch workshops were long accustomed to imitating Asian porcelain), then to be finished at Meissen before being shipped to France for sale. Others were apparently wholly decorated at Meissen, by the brilliant painter J.-G. Höroldt. The pair even managed to obtain Japanese pieces from the private collection of Augustus as models to be copied by Meissen’s craftsmen.
The success of the Meissen “Kakiemon” wares was immediate and far-reaching. Collectors throughout Europe, but especially in France, avidly purchased these exquisitely decorated wares, made in a wide variety of forms and sold for a much more reasonable price than their Japanese counterparts. Lemaire and von Hoym began to wonder –what if these wares could be passed off as authentic Japanese porcelain, and sold for a much higher price? For that to be possible, they would have to somehow remove the Meissen manufactory mark: the famous blue crossed swords. Lemaire requested that the pieces in the next delivery from Meissen be marked on top of the clear glaze, and not under it as was customary, allowing the mark to be easily removed.
In the meantime, Count von Hoym’s arrogance and Francophile tendencies were making him numerous enemies in Saxony. His business relations with the Frenchman Lemaire were at the center of accusations which led to the search of his Dresden residence in 1731. Thousands of pieces of porcelain were seized, and all were confiscated by Augustus and taken to his Japanese Palace in Dresden.
The present plate was apparently a part of this confiscated porcelain. It bears the particular blue crossed swords mark corresponding to the porcelain ordered by Lemaire in 1729 for sale in Paris, as well as the AR (Augustus Rex) monogram incised to the back. This latter mark is exceedingly rare, and was added in 1734 by Augustus III, the son of Augustus the Strong, to certain pieces seized from Lemaire and von Hoym which he wished to be conserved in the royal collection.
Count von Hoym and Lemaire were both imprisoned by Augustus III. Lemaire managed to obtain the intervention of the French government, and was released. He fled to Regensburg and his subsequent activities are lost to history. Von Hoym was less fortunate: he remained in prison, where he committed suicide in 1736. The Meissen manufactory flourished, partly because of the French trade sparked by Lemaire’s imitation Kakiemon wares, continued by Lemaire’s business partner, Jean-Charles Huet. And pieces such as the present plate have become highly collectible, rare testimonies to an affair that would mark the history of porcelain.
Among the other highlights of the auction, also from the Meissen manufactory, are a plate from the Sulkowski service, made for a Polish count who was a childhood friend of Augustus III (lot 1778, sold for CHF 30 500), and an unusually shaped Chinoiserie terrine (lot 1775) which realized CHF 22 100.
Rare plate from the Sulkowski service, Meissen, ca. 1735-1748. Estimate CHF 10 000 / 15 000. Sold for CHF 30 500. Photo Koller
D 43 cm. The center with the Alliance coat of arms Sulkowski and Stein zu Jettingen, flanked by two lions. Underglaze blue sword mark, incised mark V, potter's mark (this type of potter's mark is found on 11 plates of the Sulkowski Service; cf. Boltz, Keramos 151/96, page 76.
A comparable piece of identical dimensions can be found in the Hoffmeister Collection, in the Museum für Kunst und Gewerbe, Hamburg (1999-2009), at Bonhams, The Hoffmeister Collection, Part I, 25 November 2009, Lot 75.
Small Chinoiserie tureen, 'Olio' pot, Meissen, ca. 1725-1728. Estimate CHF 18 000 / 25 000. Sold for CHF 22 100. Photo Koller
(cf. my post Small chinoiserie tureen, 'olio' pot, Meissen, ca. 1725-1728)
Books & Autographs
The Books and Autographs auction featured a number of beautifully illustrated volumes on natural history from private collections, including an early 18th century work by Louis Renard which was one of the earliest books published with illustrations of exotic fish, made on the spot by seafarers with the Dutch East India Company (lot 353). It sold for CHF 90 500, more than double its estimate.
Louis Renard, Poissons Ecrevisses et Crabes, de diverses couleurs et figures extraordinaires, que l'on trouve autour des Isles Moluques, et sur les côtes des Terres Australes: [...] Divisé en deux tomes, dont le premier a été copié sur les originaux de Monsr. Baltazar Coyett... Le second tome a été formé sur les recueils de Monsr. Adrien Vander Stell. 2 Teile in 1 Band. Estimate CHF 40 000 / 60 000. Sold for CHF 90 500. Photo Koller
With engraved coat of arms and 100 (1 doublepage) coloured engravings after Samuel Fallours et al. Red morroco-binding of later 18th century with gilt title to spine. Very few stains to margins, otherwise beautiful copy with luminous colouring. - Former property of Fréderic-Jules Malotau de Guerne (1855-1931), a french zoologist.
François Levaillant’s work on parrots from 1801-05 was also hotly contested in the saleroom, selling for CHF 102 500 (lot 356).
François Levaillant, Histoire naturelle des perroquets. Estimate CHF 50 000 / 70 000. Sold for CHF 102 500. Photo Koller
2 volumes. Half-titles, index leaves, 145 engraved plates after Jacques Barraband, printed in colours and finished by hand by Langlois under the direction of Bouquet. Occasional browning to a few of the text leaves, very light marginal spotting to a few plates. - Contemporary red morocco signed J. M. Jacobs Antwerp, spines gilt with title on green morocco lettering-piece (edges slightly rubbed).
A complete first edition of Diderot and D’Alembert’s Encyclopaedia, including the volumes which were banned by the Vatican, fetched CHF 90 500 (lot 328).
Diderot, [Denis] - D'Alembert, [Jean Le Rond]. Encyclopédie, ou dictionnaire raisonné des sciences, des art et des métiers... 17 Textbände, 4 Supplementbände, 12 Tafelbände und 2 Indexbände in zus. 35 Bänden. Estimate CHF 50 000 / 70 000. Sold for CHF 90 500. Photo Koller
Correspondence by artists was highly prized in the Autographs auction, including a large collection of letters between Oskar Kokoschka and the long-time director of the Zurich Kunsthaus, Wilhelm Wartmann (lot 420, sold for CHF 10 000), as well as a series of letters and postcards from Edvard Munch from the 1920s and 30s (lot 421, sold for CHF 23 300).
Oskar Kokoschka (1886-1980), Collection of 16 letters, 6 cards u. Other autographs with the long-time director of the Zurich Kunsthaus, Wilhelm Wartmann, 1947-1966. Estimate CHF 3 000 / 5 000. Sold for CHF 10 000. Photo Koller
Edvard Munch, painter and graphic artist (1863-1944). Five autogr. Letters and 12 own hand. Postcards, each with signature. Furthermore, two letter punches with one's own hand. Additives Munch. Oslo, Moss, among others, about 1922-1936. Estimate CHF 3 000 / 5 000. Sold for CHF 23 300. Photo Koller
Photographs
A portrait of Marilyn Monroe from Bert Stern’s famous “last sitting”, hand-coloured by the photographer, more than quadrupled its estimate to sell for CHF 23 300 (lot 561).
Bert Stern (1929-2013), "Marilyn Monroe with orange roses" (from "The Last Sitting" for Vogue). Pigment print. Unique print, 1962/2012, 90 x 70 cm. Estimate CHF 5 000 / 8 000. Sold for CHF 23 300. Photo Koller
Handcolored by the photographer, unique copy. - This image is from the serie "The Last Sitting" and was taken six weeks before Marilyn Monroe's death. The images are partly published in Vogue magazine the same year. – In excellent condition. - Attached: Certificate of Authenticity.
An album of vintage photos of Rio de Janeiro from circa 1880 by Marc Ferrez fetched CHF 7 500 (lot 525), and a beautiful and mysterious nude by Swiss photographer René Groebli realized CHF 6 875 (lot 557).
Marc Ferrez (1843-1923), 'Rio de Janeiro'. 26 original photographs. Around 1880. Estimate CHF 6 000 / 9 000. Sold for CHF 7 500. Photo Koller
Jewellery
The top lot in the jewellery auction was a 13.70 ct Burma sapphire and diamond ring, realizing CHF 192 500 against a pre-sale estimate of CHF 160 000 (lot 2033).
13.70 ct Burma sapphire and diamond ring. Estimate CHF 160 000 / 260 000. Sold for CHF 192 500. Photo Koller
Set with 1 oval Burma sapphire of 13.70 ct, not heated, the ring shoulders set with small brilliant-cut diamonds, weighing ca. 0.20 ct. Size ca. 52.
With GIA-Report no. 1107395628, July 2009.
Signed pieces by makers such as Cartier, Chaumet and Bulgari continued to garner high prices, such as the cover lot, a pearl and diamond floral brooch by Chaumet (lot 2032, CHF 17 300), and a sapphire and diamond platinum ring signed Bulgari which realized CHF 48 500 (lot 2182).
Pearl and diamond flower brooch, by Chaumet. Estimate CHF 14 000 / 20 000. Sold for CHF 17 300. Photo Koller
White gold 750. Set at the centre with 1 Tahiti cultured pearl of ca. 14,7 mm Ø, the petals set with carved mother of pearl within a diamond-set border of ca. 3.90 ct. The stem base pavé-set with diamonds, totalling ca. 0.10 ct. Signed Chaumet, no. 877480. Ca. 9,3 x 6,7 cm.
Sapphire and diamond ring, by Bulgari. Estimate CHF 35 000 / 55 000. Sold for CHF 48 500. Photo Koller
Platinum 950. Set with 1 Ceylon sapphire of ca. 14.04 ct, not heated, flanked by baguette-cut diamonds and decorated by brilliant-cut diamonds, weighing ca. 1.00 ct. Signed Bulgari. Size ca. 61.
With GCS-Report no. 5775-2523, July 2015.
Furniture
Prices for furniture of the highest quality were strong in Koller’s 23 March auction, such as the CHF 192 500 paid by a Swiss private collector for an exquisitely inlaid bureau de dame attributed to J.-P. Latz, bearing the “c couronné”-stamped ormolu mounts which indicate a date of fabrication from the mid-late 1750s (lot 1107).
Bureau de dame "à fleurs", attributed to Louis XV, J.P. LATZ (Jean Pierre Latz, maître 1740) , the bronze mounts with "C couronné" (a tax mark which was applied to all copper-containing alloys between 1745 and 1749), Paris, ca. 1745-49. Estimate CHF 150 000 / 250 000. Sold for CHF 192 500. Photo Koller
Tulipwood, rosewood and various partly coloured precious woods, in veneer and exquisitely inlaid with flowers, leaves and cartouches and decorative frieze on all sides. Inclined front, the inside with a writing surface lined with black, gold-pressed leather. Fitted interior with large central drawer below a compartment, flanked by 1 drawer on each side. 2 secret compartments. Exquisite, matte and polished gilt bronze mounts and sabots. Free-standing. 83x47.5x(open 74)x98 cm.
Provenance: - From a French collection.
With expert opinion by S. Etienne, Paris, 2016.
A sumptuous Italian Rococo giltwood console (lot 1037) will travel to Russia to be welcomed into a private collection there (CHF 79 700), and a mid-18th century mechanical games table by Genovese craftsman Andrea Torazza will finally return home, acquired by a Genovese collector for CHF CHF 72 500 (lot 1051).
Important console "aux roses", Régence-Louis XV, Rome, ca. 1725-45. Estimate CHF 60 000 / 100 000. Sold for CHF 79 700. Photo Koller
Pierced and opulently carved gilt wood. "Giallo Antico" marquetry on "Lavica" marble top. Some losses. 199x86x99 cm.
Provenance: - From a Swiss private collection.
Games table "mécanique", Louis XV, stamped F.TE AN.A TOR.A (Andrea Torrazza, with a proven source of provenance as of 1759), Genoa, ca. 1760. Estimate CHF 60 000 / 100 000. Sold for CHF 72 500. Photo Koller
Purpleheart and tulipwood in veneer, inlaid with shamrock fillets and decorative frieze. Triple leaf, a push button in the third leaf causes a case with double-doors and 2 compartments over a drawer on each side to pop up from the leaf. 2 secret drawers for game pieces. Gilt bronze mounts and sabots. 91x46x(open 92)x84 cm.
Provenance: - Auction Sotheby's London, 23 June 1981 (Lot No. 82).
- Art trade, Genoa.
- From a very important Genoese private collection.